OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess the need for practice-wide quality improvement to support evidence-based type 2 diabetes screening for women with a history of gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) receiving primary care. We sought to add the diagnosis of GDM to the problem list of women who did not have it at baseline. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: We identified all women in our practice with a history of GDM diagnosed between 2002 and 2023, quantified the proportion with GDM documented in their problem list, and examined patient- and clinician-level factors associated with having GDM appropriately documented at baseline. RESULTS: We identified 203 women with GDM receiving primary care within internal medicine. Of the 203 women, 73 (35.0%) did not have GDM documented in their problem list. Of those without GDM included on the problem list, 52% were overdue for type 2 diabetes screening compared with 41% of those with GDM documented before our intervention. We found race, parity, and previous abnormal glycemic laboratory test results to be highly predictive of whether the history of GDM was on patients' problem list. Upon completion of our intervention, we successfully achieved a 100% documentation rate for GDM diagnosis for women who previously lacked documentation in their problem list. CONCLUSION: This work paves the way for targeted interventions aimed at improving care for women with a history of GDM, including delivery of interventions and education to prevent the onset of an appropriate clinical screening for type 2 diabetes.