A critical comparative study of the performance of three AI-assisted programs for bone age determination.

 0 Người đánh giá. Xếp hạng trung bình 0

Tác giả: Anne B Beeskow, Daniel Gräfe, Johanna Pape, Roland Pfäffle, Maciej Rosolowski

Ngôn ngữ: eng

Ký hiệu phân loại: 920.71 Men

Thông tin xuất bản: Germany : European radiology , 2025

Mô tả vật lý:

Bộ sưu tập: NCBI

ID: 188157

OBJECTIVES: To date, AI-supported programs for bone age (BA) determination for medical use in Europe have almost only been validated separately, according to Greulich and Pyle (G&P). Therefore, the current study aimed to compare the performance of three programs, namely BoneXpert, PANDA, and BoneView, on a single Central European population. MATERIALS AND METHODS: For this retrospective study, hand radiographs of 306 children aged 1-18 years, stratified by gender and age, were included. A subgroup consisting of the age group accounting for 90% of examinations in clinical practice was formed. The G&P BA was estimated by three human experts-as ground truth-and three AI-supported programs. The mean absolute deviation, the root mean squared error (RMSE), and dropouts by the AI were calculated. RESULTS: The correlation between all programs and the ground truth was prominent (R CONCLUSION: All three AI programs predict BA after G&P in the main age range with similar high reliability. Differences arise at the boundaries of childhood. KEY POINTS: Question There is a lack of comparative, independent validation for artificial intelligence-based bone age estimation in children. Findings Three commercially available programs estimate bone age after Greulich and Pyle with similarly high reliability in a central European cohort. Clinical relevance The comparative study will help the reader choose a software for bone age estimation approved for the European market depending on the targeted age group and economic considerations.
Tạo bộ sưu tập với mã QR

THƯ VIỆN - TRƯỜNG ĐẠI HỌC CÔNG NGHỆ TP.HCM

ĐT: (028) 36225755 | Email: tt.thuvien@hutech.edu.vn

Copyright @2024 THƯ VIỆN HUTECH