The accessory anterolateral talar facet (AALTF) is an anatomical variation that broadens the apex of the lateral talar process. Studies have associated it with other tarsal coalitions as a cause of rigid painful flatfoot. However, a coalition of an AALTF has never been described before. With the advent of MRI, there has been an increase in the detection of these accessory facets. Nevertheless, owing to its small size and unfamiliarity, it is not easily identified. Proper assessment of imaging findings and associated conditions is needed to confirm the diagnosis. Imaging findings in a series of four patients with painful rigid flatfoot revealed the presence of an AALTF with adjacent marrow edema and reduced joint space. This was associated with hindfoot valgus and subfibular impingement. Radiographic suspicion of a non-osseous coalition of AALTF was raised, which was confirmed intraoperatively in one of the patients and demonstrated on CT and MR images in the other patients. This case series presents rare cases of non-osseous coalition of AALTF with a new radiographic sign, the 'reverse tip of the iceberg sign'.