Ionizing radiation causes three divergent effects in the human body: On one side, tissue death (= deterministic effects) sets on, on the other side, mutations and cancer growth (= stochastic effects) can occur. In recent years, the additional phenomenon of accelerated aging has come to light. In the following, we argue that these seemingly contradictory radiation responses namely: (i) increased cancer growth, (ii) ablation of cancer tissue or (iii) deterministic senescence, share an underlying cause from damage at the lamin A C-terminus. In other words, besides the typically described genomic radiation impact, we propose an additional destabilization pathway via oxidation at the nuclear envelope. We propose five concrete hypotheses that draw a direct mechanistic model from radiation damage and cellular oxidative stress, to micronuclei and clinical symptoms. In conjunction with lamin B compensation, we might be able to explain why deterministic or stochastic responses dominate. If our model holds true, a novel target for radiotherapeutics and radiooncology arises, and a rationale to closer connect laminopathy and radioprotection research.