This research is an input to the proposed “Federal Philippines,” specifically addressing the gap on what model of federalism is suitable for the country. Recognizing that consultation from the grassroots is an important aspect of policymaking, a validated survey questionnaire that has passed a statistical reliability test was personally administered to 400 qualified respondents within a multicultural community. The result revealed which among the American, German, and Nigerian models is most favored. However, considerable differences arose within each model, with certain indicators being accepted and least accepted. Thus, a matrix of the most favored and less favored indicators is presented for strategic considerations.This research is an input to the proposed “Federal Philippines,” specifically addressing the gap on what model of federalism is suitable for the country. Recognizing that consultation from the grassroots is an important aspect of policymaking, a validated survey questionnaire that has passed a statistical reliability test was personally administered to 400 qualified respondents within a multicultural community. The result revealed which among the American, German, and Nigerian models is most favored. However, considerable differences arose within each model, with certain indicators being accepted and least accepted. Thus, a matrix of the most favored and less favored indicators is presented for strategic considerations.