Newly generated plasma cells in secondary lymphoid organs migrate to niches in the bone marrow, wherein they survive as long-lived plasma cells (LLPCs). Although LLPCs have been extensively characterized, it is still unclear what the key determinant(s) are for plasma cell longevity. One model postulates that plasma cell heterogeneity is established at the induction site, thereby instructing their longevity. Here, we found that, among newly generated IgG plasma cells, integrin β7hi marks plasma cells predisposed to home to the bone marrow, whereas integrin β7lo cells remain in secondary lymphoid organs. Mechanistically, this egress-prone fraction had a higher expression of the KLF2 transcription factor, the loss of which resulted in defective egress by downregulating S1PR1 and CD11b. Disruption of plasma cell egress results in defective antibody durability, thereby making mice more susceptible to influenza reinfection. Thus, the migration program of plasma cells established at the induction site plays a critical role in determining antibody durability.