The mitotic spindle is composed of distinct networks of microtubules, including interpolar bundles that can bridge sister kinetochore fibers and bundles that organize the spindle midzone in anaphase. The cross-linking protein PRC1 can mediate such bundling interactions between antiparallel microtubules. PRC1 is a substrate of mitotic kinases including CDK/cyclin-B, suggesting that it can be phosphorylated in metaphase and dephosphorylated in anaphase. How these biochemical changes to specific residues regulate its function and ability to organize bundles has been unclear. Here, we perform biophysical analyses on microtubule networks cross-linked by two PRC1 constructs, one a wild-type reflecting a dephosphorylated state, and one phosphomimetic construct with two threonine to glutamic acid substitutions near PRC1's microtubule binding domain. We find that the wild-type construct builds longer and larger bundles that form more rapidly and are much more resistant to mechanical disruption than the phosphomimetic PRC1. Interestingly, microtubule pairs organized by both constructs behave similarly within the same assays. Our results suggest that phosphorylation of PRC1 in metaphase could tune the protein to stabilize smaller and more flexible bundles, while removal of these post-translational modifications in anaphase would promote the assembly of larger, more mechanically robust bundles to resist chromosome and pole separation forces at the spindle midzone.