INTRODUCTION: Critical poisoning with sodium nitrite (NaNO CASE REPORT: We report the case of an overt self-intoxication by an initially unknown agent, leading to cardiac arrest. Despite prodromal signs of cyanosis, coma, desaturation, and hypotension, methemoglobinemia went unrecognized during extracorporeal cardiopulmonary resuscitation (ECPR) as the point-of-care test failed to provide methemoglobin levels, leading to untreated methemoglobinemia. The blood flowing through the oxygenator notably maintained the same brown colour. Return of spontaneous circulation was never achieved, and the patient was declared dead after 60 min of unsuccessful resuscitation. Cause of death by means of NaNO CONCLUSIONS: This case highlights the risk of failure of ECPR in the context of cardiac arrest due to methemoglobinemia, emphasizing the critical need for prompt recognition of the causative agent and early administration of antidotes.