Microplastics (MPs) have been continuously accumulating in soil, posing significant environmental concerns due to their potential toxicity and role as pollutant vectors. Effective monitoring of MPs in soils requires appropriate methods for extraction, identification and quantification. This comparative review systematically examined various methods used in MP analysis from solid matrix environments, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each technique. Soils are heterogeneous and complex matrices, which can interact differently with MPs, rendering the separation of MPs from soils a significant challenge. Key challenges include the interactions between MPs and soil organic matter and detection limitations of smaller size MP which can interfere with accurate extraction. Specialized techniques and devices are required for precise identification and quantification. Digestion can be effective in removing organic matter, although harsh digestion can degrade MPs. To improve the liability of MP analysis, it is critical to minimize steps that may reduce accuracy such as filtration, harsh digestion and inappropriate sample size. Conversely, adjusting or combining methods can enhance the precision of MP analysis. This review offers a forward-looking perspective by advocating extraction and detection approaches, thus providing a more accurate, reproducible and holistic framework for MP analysis in soils. These insights are anticipated to guide future research promote standardized protocols and enhance environmental monitoring efforts.