Efficient electrochemical hydrogenation (ECH) of organic compounds is essential for sustainability, promoting chemical feedstock circularity and synthetic fuel production. This study investigates the ECH of benzoic acid, phenol, guaiacol, and their mixtures, key components in upgradeable oils, using a carbon-supported PtRu catalyst under varying initial concentrations, temperatures, and current densities. Phenol achieved the highest conversion (83.17%) with a 60% Faradaic efficiency (FE). In mixtures, benzoic acid + phenol yielded the best performance (64.19% conversion, 74% FE), indicating a synergistic effect. Notably, BA consistently exhibited 100% selectivity for cyclohexane carboxylic acid (CCA) across all conditions. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations revealed that parallel adsorption of BA on the cathode (-1.12 eV) is more stable than perpendicular positioning (-0.58 eV), explaining the high selectivity for CCA. These findings provide a foundation for future developments in ECH of real pyrolysis oil.