While granular hydrogels are increasingly used in biomedical applications, methods to capture their rheological behavior generally consider shear-thinning and self-healing properties or produce ensemble metrics such as the dynamic moduli. Analytical approaches paired with common oscillatory shear tests can describe not only solid-like and fluid-like behavior of granular hydrogels but also transient characteristics inherent in yielding and unyielding processes. Combining oscillatory shear testing with consideration of Brittility (Bt) via the Kamani-Donley-Rogers (KDR) model, we show granular hydrogels behave as brittle yield stress fluids with complex transient rheology. We quantify steady and transient rheology as a function of microgel (composition
diameter) and granular (packing
droplet heterogeneity) assembly properties for mixtures of polyethylene glycol and gelatin microgels. The KDR model with Bt captures granular hydrogel behavior for a wide range of design parameters, reducing the complex transient rheology to a determination of model parameters. We describe the impact of composition on rheological behavior and model parameters in monolithic and mixed granular hydrogels. The model robustly captures self-healing behavior and reveals granular relaxation time depends on strain amplitude. This quantitative framework is an important step toward rational design of granular hydrogels for applications ranging from injection and