Mucin type O-glycan core elongation is typically performed by the C1GALT1, B3GNT6, and ST6GalNAc-I/-II O-glycosyltransferases. These enzymes target the Tn antigen (GalNAc-O-Thr/Ser) dictating the fate of O-glycan elongation, playing important roles in health and disease. Changes in transferase expression and glycan structure are commonly associated with diseases such as cancer, Tn-syndrome, and ulcerative colitis. Despite their significance, their substrate specificities and their biological roles remain elusive. Here, we examine the roles of flanking glycopeptide substrate charge using a library of differently charged glycopeptides and a small library of PSGL-1 Thr57 based charged glycopeptides. We found that C1GALT1 was most influenced by flanking charge preferring negatively charged substrates, while B3GNT6 and ST6GalNAc-II were less influenced, showing unique N- and C-terminal charge preferences. Interestingly, ST6GalNAc-I was not influenced by flanking charge. These charge specificities were further maintained against the charged PSGL-1 glycopeptides, although ST6GalNAc-I showed an increased preference towards a remote N-terminal positive charge. The observed charge preferences were to a large part driven by substrate interactions with the electrostatic surface of the transferase. We propose that negative flanking charge may assist C1GALT1 in targeting key glycosites such as in PSGL-1 and podoplanin. Our findings are consistent with a Golgi hierarchy, where the cis-Golgi localized GalNAc-Ts and C1GALT1 determine the site and thus fate of glycosylation, while the trans-Golgi less-specific ST6GalNAc-I provides a final capping function. This characterization of substrate charge preference furthers our understanding of how these enzymes select their substrates and may contribute to our understanding of their biological roles.