Pantoea agglomerans is one of four Pantoea species reported in the USA to cause bacterial rot of onion bulbs. However, not all P. agglomerans strains are pathogenic to onion. We characterized onion-associated strains of P. agglomerans to elucidate the genetic and genomic signatures of onion-pathogenic P. agglomerans. We collected >
300 P. agglomerans strains associated with symptomatic onion plants and bulbs from public culture collections, research laboratories, and a multi-year survey in 11 states in the USA. Combining the 87 genome assemblies with 100 high-quality, public P. agglomerans genome assemblies we identified two well-supported P. agglomerans phylogroups. Strains causing severe symptoms on onion were only identified in Phylogroup II and encoded the HiVir pantaphos biosynthetic cluster, supporting the role of HiVir as a pathogenicity factor. The P. agglomerans HiVir cluster was encoded in two distinct plasmid contexts: (i) as an accessory gene cluster on a conserved P. agglomerans plasmid (pAggl), or (ii) on a mosaic cluster of plasmids common among onion strains (pOnion). Analysis of closed genomes revealed that the pOnion plasmids harbored alt genes conferring tolerance to Allium thiosulfinate defensive chemistry and many harbored cop genes conferring resistance to copper. We demonstrated that the pOnion plasmid pCB1C can act as a natively mobilizable pathogenicity plasmid that transforms P. agglomerans Phylogroup I strains, including environmental strains, into virulent pathogens of onion. This work indicates a central role for plasmids and plasmid ecology in mediating P. agglomerans interactions with onion plants, with potential implications for onion bacterial disease management.