Aberrant accumulation and clearance of membrane proteins is associated with disease. Membrane proteins are inserted first to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). During normal growth, two quality control (QC) processes, ER-associated degradation and macro-ER-phagy, deliver misfolded and excess membrane proteins for degradation in the proteasome and lysosome, respectively. We show that in yeast during normal growth, ER-QC is constitutive, since none of the stress-induced signaling pathways-nutritional, proteotoxic, or heat-are involved. In mutant cells defective in ER-QC, misfolded or excess proteins accumulate and nutritional stress, but not proteotoxic or heat stress, can stimulate their clearance. Early during nutritional stress, clearance occurs in the lysosome through a selective micro-ER-phagy pathway dependent on the ubiquitin ligase Rsp5, its Ssh4 adaptor, and ESCRT. In contrast, only a fraction of normal membrane proteins is degraded much later via macro-autophagy. Because the pathways explored here are conserved, nutritional stress emerges as a possible way for clearing disease-associated membrane proteins.