Patients with liver disease in the intensive care unit (ICU) face a unique susceptibility to infection due to the complex immune dysfunction resulting from hepatic failure. Bacterial infections are commonly present in these patients upon arrival to the hospital, often being the primary reason for ICU admission. In contrast, invasive fungal infections (IFIs) afflict a smaller percentage of patients and are usually discovered in the course of the ICU stay. IFI diagnosis in the ICU, particularly in patients with liver disease, is often delayed or overlooked, contributing to the extremely high ICU mortality associated with IFI in these patients despite the availability of effective (and largely safe) antifungal therapy. Thus, to improve outcomes, it is crucial for intensive care clinicians to be vigilant for IFIs in patients with liver disease. This review aims to contribute to the intensive care literature in this regard. We begin with an overview of normal antifungal immunity followed by a summary of how it may become compromised in the setting of hepatic dysfunction. Next, a general discussion of IFIs in liver disease is presented and then the three most relevant fungal pathogens, namely Candida, Aspergillus, and Cryptococcus, are individually examined. This review concludes by highlighting key knowledge and practice gaps that require attention by the scientific and clinical communities in the coming years.