INTRODUCTION: We report for the first time a case of a postpubertal patient presenting with a metastatic prepubertal-type testicular teratoma. CASE DISCUSSION: A 29-year-old male with a history of corrected unilateral cryptorchidism presented with progressive bilateral lower extremity edema. Imaging revealed an inferior vena cava thrombus associated with a complex mass. A left testicular ultrasound identified a solid lesion suggestive of a germ cell tumor, leading to a left radical orchiectomy, which revealed a mature pure teratoma with no evidence of germ cell neoplasia CONCLUSION: This case illustrates that pure mature teratomas lacking chromosome 12p abnormalities, GCNIS, and other dysgenetic features, occurring in postpubertal males, cannot invariably be classified into the benign prepubertal-type teratoma category. Contrary to current paradigm, in rare cases these may represent tumors with metastatic potential.