Variations in the ecological roles of sea turtle species may lead to differentiations in ocular design and visual sensitivity to the colour spectrum. Behavioural colour preference studies in air and in water on hatchling and post-hatchling green turtles found evidence of a blue hue attractiveness when given a choice between blue, red, and yellow. This paper assessed and compared the colour preferences to singular colours via the behavioural responses of eleven hawksbill turtles and twelve green turtles at 15 months of age and at 22 months of age. Turtles were presented with one coloured water balloon per day (purple (400-450 nm), dark blue (450-490 nm), cyan (490-520 nm), green (520-560 nm), yellow (560-590 nm), orange (590-635 nm), and red (635-700 nm)). Time to contact balloons with beak and behaviours exhibited by turtles were recorded. Hawksbill turtles had the greatest level of interactions across both phases to shorter wavelengths with hue preference being between 450 and 490 nm. Green turtles consistently had the greatest level of interaction to longer wavelengths with a yellow (560-590 nm) hue preference. The results of this study support behavioural differences between two co-occurring turtle species that may reflect an adaptive preference for colour wavelengths associated with the optimal foraging niche for each.