This study investigates the effect of incorporating modified calcium carbonate whiskers, treated with tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS), to enhance the mechanical properties and sealing integrity of oil well cement under high-temperature and high-pressure (HTHP) conditions. Traditional cement systems are prone to brittleness and cracking under dynamic loads, leading to compromised wellbore sealing performance. Our findings demonstrate that fiber-toughened cement slurry improves the toughness and sealing performance of the cement annulus, maintaining gas tightness and mechanical integrity under cyclic alternating pressures at 150 °C. Specifically, the inclusion of 5% modified whisker fibers improves compressive strength by 24.5% and flexural strength by 43.3% while maintaining stable rheological and thickening properties. These results support the hypothesis that modified whisker fibers enhance the durability and sealing integrity of cement wellbores under extreme conditions, providing a practical solution for challenging cementing applications.