In an era where urban environments increasingly grapple with the challenges of an aging population, the necessity for age-friendly neighborhoods (AFNs) has never been more acute. This study investigates the implementation and effectiveness of AFN initiatives in Hong Kong, examining the alignment between policy intentions and their actual impact on the ground. Utilizing a strengths-based perspective, documentary and thematic analysis for gray literature, semi-structured interviews, and focus groups are employed to bridge existing research gaps by highlighting the subjective agency of older adults. The findings reveal that while policies are robustly designed, their execution often fails to align with older adults' actual demands and expectations. Although public policies are generally well-intentioned, they often lack specificity and fail to accommodate the unique needs of the older population fully. Serving as active agents, older adults have the potential to contribute significantly to the making of AFNs, challenging the traditional view of them as mere beneficiaries.