The fungal metabolite verticillin A is a potent and selective histone methyltransferase inhibitor. It regulates apoptosis, the cell cycle, and stress response, and displays potent activity in the suppression of tumor cell growth in several different in vivo models. Verticillin A sensitizes pancreatic cancer cells to anti-PD-1 immunotherapy by regulating PD-L1 expression. However, as with many natural products, delivery and systemic toxicity are challenges that must be overcome to advance their use as a chemotherapeutic. To both reduce systemic toxicity and improve delivery, we report a verticillin A-loaded surgical buttress, which is well-tolerated at a dose as high as 40 mg/kg. In contrast, free verticillin A administered systemically results in toxicity at a dose of 3 mg/kg. The verticillin A-loaded buttress suppresses tumor recurrence in vivo in a safe and dose-dependent manner against a highly aggressive and metastatic model of pancreatic cancer.